We all have bad habits we want to break.
We want quit smoking, nail biting, binge eating, spending, etc.
If we want to break a bad habit in the long-term, we need to understand how habits work.
Here’s what we know:
Most habits are triggered by cues. A cue can be a time of day, a location, an emotional state, other people or an immediately preceding action. Then, you’re rewarded for responding to that cue.
When breaking bad habits, many of us have been advised to replace the routine in “The Habit Loop”, to get accountable, or to change our environment…
… but this doesn’t always work, does it?
Maybe you’ve tried eating a handful of nuts instead of a candy bar – only to find your craving for sugar intensify. Or maybe you’ve tried making it hard for yourself to do the thing you didn’t want to do – only to go out of your way and do it anyway.
I know, because I’ve been there myself.
Here’s a realization I had recently:
The cue doesn’t trigger the habit; it triggers the urge to do it.
If you bite your fingernails when you’re bored (emotional state), you don’t bite your fingernails automatically, you have a choice. You feel an urge and then you choose to do it.
Between the trigger and the habit, then, is a space. And in that space lies an urge … and an opportunity to choose how to respond.
Here’s what I’m proposing: forget breaking bad habits; instead, manage your urges to do them.
Why? Because if you can manage your urges, you can sidestep bad habits entirely.
To do this, you need to learn how to surf them.
Let’s look at how we can do that.
Surfing The Urge
“Urge Surfing” or “Surfing The Urge” is a mindfulness-based technique I learned from Kelly McGonigal in her wonderful book, The Willpower Instinct.
To surf the urge, you must pay close attention to the urge without trying to change it or get rid of it.
Instead of distracting yourself from the urge or hoping it will go away, get a good look at it.
Ask yourself:
- What does the urge feel like?
- What thoughts are going through my mind?
- What does the urge feel like in my body?
- Do I feel tension in my throat or my stomach?
Stay with the sensations for at least one minute and if you give in, forgive yourself. This is a skill and requires a lot of practice.
There’s one thing that’s important to remember about urges: whether you choose to give into them or not, they always pass eventually.
Don’t fight the urge to do a bad habit; ride it.
Diwant says
So many times I’ve come up to a wall in self discipline, I find you’ve posted an entry that’s in the same line as how I’ve been considering breaking through that wall. My brother and I termed our approach momentary discipline, or discipline in the moment. It’s very much what you’ve described, where we are paying attention to the urges in the moment. We are playing one step beyond the observance in that
1. Where when we feel an urge in the direction of what we want (new habit), we ride the wave and push it as far as we can.
2. If we feel an urge in another direction (old habit), we either are trying to
– a) let the urge pass,
– b) substitute the urge if we can (i.e. drink warm honey water when we crave sugar),
– c) feed the urge if it is very strong (otherwise we are dealing with pain bodies, right?), or if we are feeling especially strong then
– d) respond to the urge with a new choice, a ritual micro habit (that’s a tool I got from you!) like a five minute meditation from where we kick into a new routine, interrupting the old habit loop by slowing down and reorienting.
What do you think? Again, loved your post. Thanks Sam!
Sam Thomas Davies says
“Momentary Discipline”. I love that. Thanks for reading Diwant.
jackn says
This is good and helpful.
Thank you.
Sam Thomas Davies says
Thanks for reading. 🙂